Saturday, February 03, 2018

WoW buildings review

Note: update below

One thing as a starter... The company may be called WOW, but the products are definitely NOT WOW.

We placed an order with WoW in September, planning to use the buildings at a con in December. After a lot of back and forth emails, we finally got our stuff yesterday (1 February). However, we were quite disappointed with the delivery (understatement). The packaging was crap: all the printed wall and roof pieces were just put loose in the box, not packed by building, no documentation, and with just 2 inflatable plastic packing bags as protection. Due to everything being loose, some sharp edges had perforated the bags during transport, so they didn't offer any protection anymore. This caused some of the pieces to be cracked.

Sadly the quality of the contents was beyond belief. Apart from damage caused by the crap packaging, most of the pieces are either warped or stringy, doors and shutters are only partly printed, corners and sides have come loose from the printer's ground plate during the printing process, causing warping, sides have come loose from flat pieces, dirt from the extruder has come out causing lumps on walls and roofs, some roofs are just long loose ends of string - in their entirety! All of this is obviously a result of (very) bad 3d printing (wrong temperature, no attention during the start of the process, etc...). It is also very visible and there is no way the seller did not notice this while packing. Which means he deliberately sent us products of bad quality, or couldn't care less that he was sending us crap. Not sure which is worse.

Obviously, from other comments on facebook, he must have good products, which makes is only worse that what we got is this bad. We were really looking forward to adding these buildings for Arnhem and other Dutch games, so we are extremely disappointed.

Equally obviously we opened a paypal dispute, and contacted the seller for a full refund. Waiting for his feedback now.

WOW buildings are trading from this website and from a facebook page.

Update: Paul has reached out to us in the meantime and offered to reprint and resend on Monday. We can also keep what we received to do with as we please (e.g. make ruins). I will update this blogpost with any news that comes out, and we will do a new review if and when we get the new delivery. He also mentions the light grey bits were bad prints that he added for us to use as ruins or whatever.

Update 2: see a new blogpost on this matter here


























2 comments:

Joakim Ström said...

Looking at his Kickstarter för stl-files for home-3D-prininting from last year I can see that what you have seen is not an isolated event. Seems lots of people don't agree on his definition on OpenLOCK compatible, that files are corrupt, badly thought out etc. Quite a few backers haven't received their files, there is name-calling etc.
I would certainly stay clear of WOW
Sad!

Unknown said...

I bought a number of WoWbuilding Kickstarters when I first got my 3d printer, excited at the shear number of cool looking files (500 dollars plus). Paul's work is prolific, and quantity has a value all of it's own. They are work however--lots of voids in models, unprintable areas, pieces that don't quite connect, files that are cut to fit on a print bead versus planned to be printed as parts and then fitted together. He'll fix problems when pointed out, but I recommend steering clear because problems are consistent and abundant. He doesn't do test prints--he seems to believe that slicer colors will tell one whether something will print or not (sigh). There's no comparison between his work and a company like printable scenery.